I'm sorry I didn't want to create a whole new post but I wanted to get my message across and that. So I would appreciate no one hides this until the guys in charge and that have seen it.
I like the fact the new league is up and running, and I appreciate the effort DT put into it, hes done a brill job but there are a few aspects to the league that makes it to me "broken".
Are the main culprits.
Personally I think the leaders need not to be redone, but maybe reconsidered.
1.The Black Letter (Rarely Used)
I'm fine with TBL being a leader, hes a good battler but he left the site a while ago and rarely comes back to chat.
3.Sir Sewaddle (Underused)
With all due respect (and I have discussed this with others) SS is not the best. He needs to improve allot to be a leader IMO and other users such as Gligurr and XtremeKiller are not only better but more deserving. Now I'm sure there are valid reasons for this, or not, but I have challanged him twice as has Scizorman with the response of " " . Yeah nothing. This annoys me, don't ask to be a leader if your just going to run every challenge you get. Sorry. :(
4.Ninja (Challenge Cup)
5.SentByRavens (Little Cup)
Little Cup is not his strongest point at all, and he would really like to trade for Ou but then Df would loose Ou and would want Uu. Obviously SS has UU. Maybe if we replaced SS for Gligurr, Gligurr could battle Lc as he experience in Lc. This would allow Ben to battle in the only tier he plays in and Df to play in Uu if he wants. Or maybe the more practical idea that we don't force players to play in any tier, let them free to choose. After all we already have allot of variety.
7.Dr Flame (Overused)
So as you can see i have listed the weak spots in the league and I'm sure you will mostly agree. The E4 are brilliant and if we maybe changed the gym leaders up a bit we would have a pretty solid league.
Why did the last league collapse?
Stupid rules and disorganization. Its a gym battle it should be one battle. Not best out of 7. No one has time to battle that much. Nor does anyone want to. Personally I would prefer it if only Ninja and Kyron to battle battle best of 3. Trachy's rules seem reasonable.
A gym battle in the games is one battle right? Its just a way to learn the team if you lost and try again.
Hax (3-5 significant cases, which will be reviewed by a mod. YOUR responsibility to record battle)
-They seem reasonable. Credit to Ehill
Erm where are they. I believe that we have not seen any yet that are not league related. For those who were not around at the peak of the league we had almost 40 challengers. So far we have 0. It is not restricted to people in the league.
Personally I think Trachy should do what he did last time and try the league decided whether or not the league is sturdy enough. Testing the leaders so there are no real weak spots.
Just my opinions and suggestions. I know they were only short but they were not really suitable for a comment.