PokeBase Battle Subway Meta-PokeBase Q&A

Pokemaster, what are your thoughts on comment necroposts?

1 vote

Answers of course are banned due to the fact that it just becomes point-grubbing. But comments are a different matter and I would like to know if we should hide comments on questions that are older.

asked Mar 8, 2013 by trachy

1 Answer

3 votes
 
Best answer

I don't think it's a huge deal as new comments only show up in the "All Activity" page, not on the home page or Questions page. Having said that, comments should be on topic and regarding the particular post.

So if the question was "Which Pokemon has the highest stats" and someone answered Arceus, a comment like "Arceus is my favorite Pokemon" that's pretty pointless. Or a comment like "This is a good answer" - the post should just be upvoted instead.

So pointless comments, yes please do hide those if you spot any, otherwise don't worry about it.

answered Mar 10, 2013 by Pokemaster
selected Jul 27, 2013 by trachy