Why do tag suggestions work this way?!

Question

In Pokebase, it suggests tags that are words from the titles of questions that the site assumes to be related. It does not suggest tags that are words in the question itself. This is very annoying because the tags often have nothing to do with the question that I'm trying to ask.

EDIT: Suggestion: include as many tags as possible that use words that show up in the question title.

Comments

It must be sooooo hard to type out your own tags :P

---

Oh! Yes! I know why it works this way!
It's a new idea I have!
It's called...
PML (Pokemaster Logic)

---

I'm pretty sure that "lolwhy" tag must also be appearing without any coherent reason when you ask a question. But it still does manage to find it's way into the question ;)

---

^^
Crustle did it :O

---

My keyboard sometimes freezes. It takes longer for me to type things than for most other people. I'm sorry.

---

That can be irritating... but to be honest, I think this is still the most efficient way of suggesting tags. There really isn't any other way either, since there's no way the site can provide links based on what you're thinking rather than typing down.

---

Oh Qwerty, you poor naive thing. Don't you know that the government knows what you're thinking right now, and they are using that information to predict your entire future? Where have you been living, under a rock?

---

I'm just saying that it should suggest tags with words directly from the question title. Apparently the site does not.

---

It does…?

Oh wait. I think I've caught your confusion. Do you mean the tags that appear right after you have written the title of the question?

If so, then those are not suggested tags. They are example tags. Unless you type something, that is what is gonna show.

---

I once had a question about Rotom, and the word "Rotom" was in the title, but it did not suggest a Rotom tag. Instead, there was a Flygon tag, even though the question had nothing to do with Flygon.

---

They're just examples. Whether they are right or not isn't their purpose. They're only really there for showing novices what people expect in a tag.

---

Of course it said Flygon. Everything is Flygon if you think hard enough O.o

---

I asked a question about Smogon tiers and they gave me the 3ds and ingame tags, but neither smogon nor tier showed up.

Answer 1

This is due to a limitation in the software. It's most likely due to the fact that the title should contain the most appropriate words for the question, while the content of the post can include all sorts of stuff like URLs, Markdown code, or HTML code if the site was using a HTML editor instead of Markdown.