PokéBase - Pokémon Q&A
0 votes
103,627 views

Need a good hm slave for platinum.

Thank you

by
edited by
Bibarel is the best HM slave in Pokemon, and you can get Bidoof the second you start the playthrough.

2 Answers

2 votes
 
Best answer


The best HM slave is definitely Bibarel, capable of learning Cut, Surf, Strength, Rock Smash, Waterfall, and Rock Climb. Bidoof and Bibarel are common and obtainable early. Tropius is available later, in the Great Marsh, and learns Cut, Fly, Strength, Defog, and Rock Smash, perfectly complementing your beaver. Alternatively, Starly can learn both HMs that Bibarel can't and is also available before the first Gym, but it doesn't do anything Tropius can't.

A good "team" of HM slaves is one Bibarel and one Tropius, which together learn all eight HM moves and allow you to manage experience among a smaller battling party of four members.

A slightly worse team of HM slaves consists of two Bibarel and one Starly, which allows you to teach every available HM with Pokemon available earlier. This has little practical bearing, however, as many HMs aren't obtainable until after you catch Tropius anyway.

by
edited ago by
Why would you use Bibarel and Rhydon when you can use 2 Bibarels? Why would you use Skarmory when you can use Smeargle?
Smeargle would take more effort than Skarmory, because it only learns Sketch. Skarmory can learn Fly by just using a TM. Ryhdon was for the sake of variety, but I suppose another Bibarel would be better.
Can you add Tropius to the answer? If you use Tropius and Bibarel, you don't need another Bibarel.
0 votes

Considering how many moves one can lean,
Prinplup learn 6 in 8, except rock climb and Fly
Empoleon is the best HM, learning 7 HMs except Fly

Considering the source and combo
Bibarel / Empoleon + Tropius will be the best.

Also, considering timeline as below:
> After 3rd Gym, Breed Empoleon at Solaceon City
> After 4th Gym, [Fly] available
> Before/After 5th Gym (Great Marsh), Catch Tropius
> Before 6th Gym, Move Deleter to delete HMs.

If one get a female Piplup and bad nature
Breed a better one and use the starter as HM slave will also make sense
The new Piplup will still catch up considering its just 3 gym.
And the starter Prinplup can level up and become Empoleon in breeding centre, which is quite simple as well.

by
Breeding and evolving an Empoleon is a lot slower than catching a wild Bibarel.