PokéBase - Pokémon Q&A
3 votes

Okay so ash was battling against the gym leader roxanne and ash told pikachu to use thunder on geodude.The thunder was effective and geodude was unable to battle.Electric type moves have no effect on ground but in this episode it has been effective.Was it an error?

asked by
Is this whe he vs Brock?
pickachu hadn't thunder yet....

2 Answers

1 vote
Best answer

beacuse it's in the anime.in the anime all things can happen.Example: we've seen this taillow surviving pikachu's thunder.

answered by
selected by
surviving is natural that can happen but the move obviously should have no effect
Scrafty why are you never on chat  anymore
2 votes

The anime never show any mistakes related to the "logic" the Pokemon world employ

Many times in many episodes, they explain many things about their "logic", but most people, don't pay atention to theese details and them sometimes they don't understand how some things could happen.

Well, for that in particular was pretty easy to understand, many times in the anime in many seasons, many characters explain how and why electric moves have no effect in ground Pokemon and how and why they are weak against grass.

One of the best time they explain this, was in this episode: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pj9dxxF-a3c

go for 16:50 minutes

Brock will explain!!


Max ask why pikachu thunderbolt work normally against treecko, since treecko was a grass type and eletric moves was weak against grass types. Brock then will explain that, the eletric move worked normally, because it hit treecko when he was jumping!!
Brock explain that electric moves are weak against grass and have no effect on ground Pokemon, because the eletricity flow throught the body of the Pokemon and hit the ground or tree right away dispersing the energy, them the grass Pokemon take minor damage and the ground Pokemon take no damage!
But when the Pokemon is not on the ground, like hoving or jumping, like in the case of treecko, the move work normally!! Because the Pokemon is not on the ground, so the energy has not to defuse on it!

Knowing about this, Ash and many other characters when facing grass or ground Pokemon, they prefer to hit the Pokemon when he is hoving or jumping, so the electric move work normal.


Then, in the fight against Roxane, Ash waited the right time to hit geodude with a electric move, the time when geodude stop the roll out and start hoving again.


I would like if you mark this as the best anwers to this question, so many other people could understand that question too. Thanks!

answered by