Meta-PokéBase Q&A
12 votes
918 views

This post covers exactly why I think we need more moderation. We do need more moderation in chat, and the reason why I'm making this thread is because we haven't gotten any yet. I think it's well- needed in general, the role, since it's kind of "taboo" giving out editor status, in fear of it being mistreated. I genuinely think a role that's for the chat, just for the chat, would be great.

PX has been telling me for the past few months "get enough points and I'll propose that we promote you to editor", but honestly, that has been a hassle and somewhat draining-- it's hard to grind points. Probably not just for me, but for everyone. I think if there was a chatmod role with basic kick powers to trusted users, that would be cool. Regular user but kick powers.

If you been in chat, you'll know I'm active 8+ hours a day helping keep stuff sane and reporting to staff, and a lot of users have been mentioned #tyforchatmod. I think a lot of users trust and support me being promoted since generally I'm unbiased and am dedicated to keeping this place safe.

Users such as X, Y, SYL, Flaweon, KygorePulse, PX, CC, and even slightly Fizz too have been in generally in support of the Tyforchatmod movement, but obviously, that'll never happen without the role existing. Also, I'm in the same timezone as HT, so that would work out for that.

tea Today at 6:58 PM
hey fizz can i be promoted to chatmod
Lockgd Today at 6:59 PM
yes but chatmod doesn't exist
tea Today at 6:59 PM
thank u, i am spiritually the official chatmod now
Lockgd Today at 7:01 PM
works for now i suppose :p

TL;DR the chatmod role should exist and a solid amount of users agree that I'd make a decent chatmod, PM notice me

Sorry, some people been kind of upset about the self-nomination aspect of this post? I want to clarify that this post is yeah, well I'm advocating for myself, but that's because I'm a prime example who been generally trusted and would be down for it, but also it's something the chat needs in general. I'm using myself as an example here because a lot of users trust me, and I can use my own personal experiences in the post.

HOWEVER, this is something the chat needs in general. Many users agree that chat needs a few extra helping hands, and yes, while there's a good handful of users next in line for editor, that doesn't mean they'll be any more active in the social aspect of the site. I agree that there's some users who deserve a promotion more than I, but the ones I can think of on the top of my head aren't usually active in chat.

So then, what's the point? If we just promote people who have little to no interest in the chat aspect to editor, there still will be an issue with lack of chat moderation.

Tl;dr 2, sorry that I nominated myself in the last post, but I do honestly think it's something needed specifically for the good of that chat. Editor promotion =/= moderated chat, therefore I firmly believe there should be a role for it.

by
edited by
If the chamod role existed, it would be perfect for you.
Yes, you are on chat a lot, which is good for chat mod. I- don't know if I agree with just plain asking in meta, but I don't think you would be bad as chat mod. As for grinding points... well, easy peasy. It may not be easy to you, yes, but Mod with 1k points is... a bit low. Sorry, I don't want to offend you, just stating my opinion. But if you were chat mod, I think you'd be good for the job. The only problem is points, obviously. 1k points and mod is like me with 600 points and Expert or Editor. I do think there should be more Mods, as the active Mods rn are PX and Fizz. Oh and PM, but doesn't count.

TL;DR I think 1k points is a bit too low points to be Mod, that's like me being Editor or Expert. But you as chat mod would be good, as PX is the only Mod I know that goes onto chat. You are on chat a lot, making you suitable for the job.; Only problem is points.
To be fair i don't understand why sumwun is always against Ty? Anyways, i can agree with the other people here that the self nomination is a bit, eh? But Ty definitely needs the role. As for J, no, not at all. I don't know if you know, but there was something called a 'gligurr' situation and it could happen in chat. Also a lot of people in chat get into squabbles so they also would probably just kick out of anger lmao.

Also aren't we underestimating how much Ty is online here? Like 8 hours is a lot lmao, and no Editor can surpass that combined with being such a neutral voice in chat. Ultimately i definitely do agree with Felix to an extent, let's get the role first before we start discussing nominations.
thank you syl <3
sumwun is just giving an opinion, don't make this personal in anyway

I did a post on why experts shouldn't be allowed to kick, so go look that up if you want to know why. Tldr it doesn't make any actual sense.

I don't know how much I supported the chatmod idea before (I know I talked about it in chat a bit) but my stance now is more in line with the "just promote more editors" stance.

I don't have anything against anyone who has put someone else or themselves forward, but I feel that the role is unnecessary. The main problem is just not having auth during US timezones. Literally one extra editor can cover that role.


Additionally, I will echo Felix and mention that people seem to be using this as a way to sell themselves for a promotion. I don't think anyone is being malicious or anything, but in general new Auth gets pushed by old Auth, with community blessing. We should have a feature confirmation first, and then suggest later.

In other words, you guys are getting way too ahead of yourselves. Calm down a bit.

Please log in or register to answer this question.