PokéBase - Pokémon Q&A

# Does this Sinistea encounter percentage mean that Authentic Sinistea is easier to find in some weather?

462 views

So according to Bulbapedia, the chances of finding a Fake Sinistea in the Old Cemetery ranges from 19% to 13%, while the chance of an Authentic Sinistea remains a 1% chance.

My high school math knowledge thinks that this means that you have a higher chance of encountering an Authentic Sinistea, (since when you encounter Sinistea you don't know if it's authentic or not,) if you're hunting in thunderstorms when Phony Sinistea's encounter rate is 13%. Is this true?

Here’s an upvote for helping me with my shiny hunting
Why thank you

No. Phony and Antique Sinistea are considered by the game to be entirely separate encounters, so the chance of finding Antique Sinistea is always 1% (except during Sandstorm where it can't be found).

You are imagining the game deciding to spit out Sinistea, then deciding whether to make it Antique. That's not what it does. It's 1% of all the possible encounters in the area, not 1% of Sinistea.

The data would be presented differently if the Antique encounter rate were a fraction of Sinistea's total encounter rate.

I'm aware of the context for this question -- the answer is correct, but the percentages it gives are probably not a helpful way to think about the Antique odds.

by
selected
Sorry for editing this a few times. First I assumed KRLW's answer said the same thing as the question (wrong), then I assumed the question talks about the 1% being contained within the Phony probability (wrong).
Thanks fizz