They would gain editing powers immediately upon reaching 6,000 points, because that's how PokeBase is set up. That can be changed easily by Pokemaster if we foresee a problem.
Assigning the "Expert" title is a manual process, so we can just not give it to somebody we think doesn't deserve it.
would the mods be like “nah fam you kinda suck, sorry”
If the situation calls for it, yes.