Meta-PokéBase Q&A
1 vote
441 views

I noticed that necroposting is getting much more common lately, which is really annoying, so I had an idea: What if we just close old, solved questions (don't hide them though, it might be useful to others!)? That way, no one can interact with the post anymore - but they still can view it and upvote it, unless a mod decided to close it.

An exception for questions like "What are all the current Pokemon games?" since they will need constant updates from time-time.

by
I don't like this suggestion. Most "necroposting" is comments, which can happen on closed questions. Also it's usually possible for someone to discover that an answer is wrong just by playing the game.

1 Answer

2 votes
 
Best answer

PSA: "Necroposting" is allowed. If you have a better answer to an old question, something new to add, an error to correct, etc. then it does not matter how old the question is. You are allowed to post anything that will help people reading the question in the future.

What you aren't allowed to do is post random off-topic comments on questions, including both new and old ones. We're aware there are a few new users doing this currently. We've given warnings to them and hidden their posts, and we'll keep doing that. If it doesn't stop, then they will be banned.

There doesn't need to a dramatic change in response to a few problem users. Closing old questions means the questions can never be updated again, which is a problem for a site like this that seeks to give the most helpful and correct answers. It would also be an extreme moderation burden. It's not the root cause of the problem, so it doesn't need to be fixed.

by
selected by
I see. Thanks for taking the time to answer, Fizz!
Fizz, maybe necroposting should be banned and those posts should be hidden.
@SimplyYK One of the people this answer is talking about is you -- bear that in mind before you make recommendations for how the platform should be moderated.