PokéBase - Pokémon Q&A

Wall for Froggyfrogsock (page 3)

Hey, I wanted to check in. I know I blabbed a lot last night. You taking it all okay?
Dec 6 by SiIver
Probably because of its ability then. Shadow shield cuts damage in half
Dec 6 by Bird???
Womp womp
Dec 6 by Jhnfui
Stalking walls and read the below. I generally wouldn't do this but in the interest of helping keep the site alive I suppose I will.

Ty's pretty well described the problems some people (or, at the very least, me) have with your answers. They're *good* answers, but they tend to be a bit more wordy than necessary. I think the most important thing to do when writing most answers is to make the important information easy to find and consume. For example, if the question asks if there are any bug and fire type pokemon, the answer should be "Yes, they are [Pokemon]." Generally, the simpler the question, the shorter the answer should be. If YOU asked a simple question, would you want to read a whole paragraph? If you think that extra information that isn't directly obvious would be helpful for the matter at hand, you should add it, but I'd highly recommend emboldening the most important parts of the answer so people can easily find what they're looking for.
For example, I think that everything after the first sentence of the important note here is unnecessary. A full guide about the changes isn't necessary, as your answer (to a question specific to Leafeon/Glaceon) should already cover the relevant information. Things like linking to Eevee's page are also unnecessary. It's not hard to find and it's somewhat distracting. This is a forum, not Wikipedia. https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/130553/how-can-you-evolve-eevee-to-leafeon-glaceon-if-it-is-level-100?show=435942#a435942

Just to be clear, long answers are not always bad, the question just needs to warrant having an answer of significant length. Side notes should be relevant and useful to the question. I wrote an answer a while ago regarding the genre of the music of RSE and a good chunk of the answer wasn't about what genre the music is, but rather that genre is a social construct, and while I don't think it's quite as obvious as it should be in the answer, the entire point of that section is to ask if genre even really matters. I'd also like to point out that I acknowledged that it could be seen as fluff (and also gave my justification for wanting to add it). Could the answer be "the genre is classical hope i helped :)"? Yes, absolutely. That's why I put certain parts of the text in bold; if you read just the bold parts you'll pretty quickly get a simple answer. That being said, I'm far more knowledgeable about music than most people, as I went to college for it, so I felt that I could give a more in-depth analysis of the music and better explain how I came to the conclusion I did (aided by my knowledge of music), why that might not necessarily be a very good conclusion, and explain why coming to a super definitive conclusion is neither necessary or possible. Long? Yes. Too long? Probably. That being said, if you're genuinely interested in the what and why of the answer, I think that it's all worth reading.
https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/329546/what-genre-is-pokemon-ruby-sapphires-music?show=434225#a434225
I'm probably going on a tangent here, but my point is that you need to be able to justify what you add to your answers. They should obviously directly answer the question at hand, be easily readable, and cite sources. Very occasionally there may be an underlying question or piece of information you should address. For example, https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/189937/was-volcarona-originally-meant-to-be-a-legendary?show=435898#a435898 I address the question at hand, and then I address why people might have thought it was a legendary Pokemon, which I felt was relevant to the answer. Did I overexplain? Probably. But I also covered all of my bases. I could have said "people probably thought this because volcarona is an overworld encounter" but I felt that it'd also be worth mentioning that that's the only characteristic that volcarona shares with legendary pokemon.

All that rambling aside, most questions don't need that sort of information, and you can give a good, thorough answer without stepping on the toes of readability and brevity.

https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/435688/how-many-mew-events-have-happened-in-the-world?show=435697#a435697
Here's another one. The answer to the title of the question is in the first paragraph, in bold. If you're just curious about how many mew events there are, there you go. Right there, close the tab and never think about it again. The description of the question, however, seems to be asking more about how many unique mews there are total, which the answer addresses by elaborating on the fact that some of the events are pretty much the same. Hope this all makes sense, I might just be talking myself in circles.

I want to talk about humor in answers, but really the most definitive thing is keep it relevant and don't let it distract from the matter at hand. Don't just force a joke into an answer. Add one if it makes sense. A user I'd like to bring to your attention is Toucanadian. A beast back in the day, and I fondly remember him for writing great answers that occasionally had a funny sidenote. Some of the humor has probably aged poorly and is no longer funny, but it may be worth checking out some of his answers.
https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/285908/whats-with-decidueyes-typing?show=285921#a285921 This one works jokes (or just fun stuff in general) into it very fluidly. Little thinks like referring to Incineroar as Tony the Tiger and needlessly clarifying that stilt owls are extinct help the long answer feel less stiff. The formatting is also great.

Nobody has a problem with you personally. As for me, a lot of it is just that I tend to not like being around young people. Even high schoolers I tend to not enjoy the company of. That being said my personal opinions on anybody do not affect what I think of the work they do. I think sumwun is a pain in the ass and I'm not really fond of him on a personal level (if you can even get personal with that guy), but I think he's one of the best contributors the site's ever had. Likewise, I'm quite fond of Ty on a personal level, but sometimes they do things in ways that I don't always agree with because we're different people with incredibly different personalities and incredibly different ways of interacting with people. Just to be clear, my problems with your contributions to the site have nothing to do with who/what you are and are specific to the contributions. I know I don't always come off as a particularly nice person, so I thought it was worth mentioning. I'm bullshitting 90% of the time I'm here.
Dec 6 by Hellfire Taco
re: https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/136550/my-eevee-is-lv-100-but-i-want-it-to-be-a-glaceon-what-should-i-do#:~:text=%E2%80%932,votes
This got downvotes because i already answered it and my answer was up-to-date and accurate. mine wasn't the best answer, but it didn't need another. additionally, the ice rock is in BDSP, so the statement "only in LA" isn't accurate. i think it's also in SWSH but i won't want to factcheck that :P

re: if you would be expert, i think you have a lot of potential, even as you are now. you are active, you're willing to learn and accept feedback, and you're growing a lot. i think you're incredibly smart as well.  i think it's clear you care about the site and others as well. assuming you meet all the criteria and we were accepting, i would nominate you. however, that is not my decision alone to make. it would be up to everyone.

if expert is something you want, i think you should look to the other staff members for advice and feedback. Hellfire Taco is probably your biggest critic. He's silly, but he is well-respected among staff. I think it would be wise to try to get his approval (you can't win his approval by being his pal; it would have to be through hard work, he's a tough guy!). Honestly, even for current issue, he could probably give you more and better feedback than I can. Fizz is also always looking for potential, and keeping tabs on people, even if he isn't active socially. If you ever want an unbiased, blunt opinion, sumwun is your creature. it is so incredibly smart, and they can be so factual, honest, and unbiased.
Dec 6 by SiIver
It's okay that points are a motivator! That IS the purpose of points, after all. Even I'm super motivated for points (I want to hit 13k by the end of the month). I'm happy to hear that you want to learn and share your knowledge with others. We feel like some of your filler and fun commentary can be a bit much. SOME fun commentary is fun, but don't let it distract from the purpose of the post. I'm totally fine if you want to answer for the frogs :P

here's some examples of posts that i think have too much going on (I AM being a bit hyper-critical):
https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/435045/how-to-unlock-all-hair-colours-in-legends-z-a (the comment about me, lol)
https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/325372/has-there-ever-been-a-pokemon-game-with-dlcs (a lot of links, very drawn out; it would've been fine as a simple list)
https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/130553/how-can-you-evolve-eevee-to-leafeon-glaceon-if-it-is-level-100 (the thing J removed)
https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/29274/are-there-any-bug-and-fire-types (extra unneeded formatting, sprites, links, and screenshot of showdown as source)
https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/320184/how-do-you-make-a-kangaskhan-into-a-mega-kangaskhan (this could do without the abbreviation guide)
https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/141562/can-smeargle-sketch-signature-moves (doesn't need the disclaimer :P)

Basically, you have BEAUTIFUL answers you tend to be a little much at times, especially the older ones. I think it's awesome you want to be detailed and resourceful, but simple can be best.

On my own personal note, I find Bolding and paragraphing are good ways to help emphasize what's most important in the post, and adding tl;dr (too long; didn't read) as a quick summary at the bottom can help. Personally, I usually do the following:

------
(the answer summary in one or two sentences, bolded) + facts or details to prove or explain why the answer is what is is.

[Source]

(my ideas on the topic to explain what I think, or additional things that i think are related. this is where I do personal statements like "I" or "think". don't put too much; just what is needed. i would put "for the frogs :P" at the end here if i really needed to.)

IN CONCLUSION if it was a longer ramble (repeat answer as short as possible, bolded)
-------

^ that's how I answer. you do NOT need to copy this format. But i hope that maybe gives you an idea of what we're looking for. here's an example of me doing this format and rambling my thoughts, with extra details: https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/162529/is-meloettas-piroutte-forme-a-boy

and here's an example (your question!) where i kept it super simple and to the point. you even said it was incredibly simple! you can see all i did was answer it first  upfront, and then supported my argument: https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/432920/when-and-how-have-the-base-full-odds-shiny-chances-changed

and this is me doing that with "extra details":
https://pokemondb.net/pokebase/432229/is-arceus-officially-mythical-or-legendary

simple answers are not bad answers!
it's generally not needed to add personal thoughts, opinions, or extra detail unless the question requires you to make an educated guess based off of circumstance (like the meloetta gender question).

(will continue next wallpost)
Dec 6 by SiIver
Was the Lunala full health? Talking about the thing you said in chat
Dec 6 by Bird???
I just saw your post on Fizz's wall about Experts and I don't think you got a reply, so I want to comment on that real quick lol. Mods can promote anyone to expert at any time, however we only do it during promotions. We host promotions about once per year OR as needed. When we promote people to expert before 6000, there's a few unspoken requirements, like account age, activity, knowledge, activity in community, and maturity. Even if someone meets all those requirements, we only will promote if there's a site need for it. We discussed promotions last month, and we agree we have enough active staff at the moment for the level of activity, so we are not considering promoting anyone at this time. It will likely be another year before we consider promotions again. However! We will always honour the 6000 point tradition. So, if you want Expert, you would need to get 6000 points for it at this time. (I will answer your questions in another wallpost)
Dec 6 by SiIver
mod abuse!
Dec 6 by Your Excellency