PokéBase - Pokémon Q&A
1 vote
144 views

In most if not all games, the moves self-destruct and explosion have animations that show some fire balls or a stereotypical explosion which has fire. Despite all of this, the moves self-destruct and explosion are still normal type. Being normal type moves hinders their potential competitively since they can't hit ghost types. One final statement is the fact that these moves are physical, but why? The moves never damage the other Pokemon physically. If draining kiss can be special then surely self-destruct and explosion can.

by
Normal was a physical type when the moves were introduced I believe
Maybe most self-destruct and explosion users had higher physical attack, but egg bomb should be special by that logic.

2 Answers

4 votes
 
Best answer

According to Wikipedia

"An explosion is a rapid increase in volume and release of energy in an extreme manner, usually with the generation of high temperatures and the release of gases."

Explosions are not made of fire. Think of them like a balloon, and everyday item that has energy inside of it (Helium, Air, etc.). If you try to pump more air into the balloon without letting the air escape, there will be too much and it will pop. If you think of it like that, it should make more sense. It is not a fire type move because the "energy" (Air in the Balloon example) does not need to be fire. It is a physical move because you are causing an overflow in energy, making it all let out at once. The visual part of the explosion is the energy bursting out which is often the reaction we see. Example, Coke and Mentos Creates a small explosion. The physical reaction needs somewhere to go, and that is what you see happening. The Air from the popped balloon does the same, except you can't see them.

TL;DR Not all explosions are made of Fire, so why should they be fire type. It is a physical move because the energy caused by the explosion would be a real entity's energy.

Hope I helped and Made Sense. Sorry I went all Science Nerd there.

Source
My brain connecting the dots and the Wikipedia article on explosions.

Edit: sumwun made a point that Coke and Mentos made a physical reaction but you knew what I ment (hopefully)

by
selected by
Mentos and Coke explosions don't involve chemical reactions. source: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/bring-science-home-coke-mentos/
1 vote

That's how Game Freak wanted it.

Explosion and Self Destruct could be considered Physical because of shrapnel flying towards the opponent, maybe.

The typing could be for balance reasons. How would you, an innocent Bug Pokemon just trying to have a friendly battle, feel about getting nuked by a super effective, base power 200 move? These moves being Normal makes their damage not quite so obscene, as Normal is super effective against nothing.

But it really is just Game Freak logic, and we'll never truly know until they tell us.

Hope I helped!

by