Meta-PokéBase Q&A
1 vote
328 views

Ok, I know at first this question may sound ridiculous. But I have many reasons to ask this.

  1. For new users, their questions have to be check and approved before letting it out in public. Mods / whoever checks it should be making sure that it follows the rules, so if you close a question, maybe you're not doing it enough, because a lot of the reasons why questions get closed is because it breaks the rules. But for new users, their questions get checked and approved!

  2. For users who have been here a longer time, they should know by now not to ask questions that would break the rules. But even that aside, I've never seen someone with more than 100 points ask a question that breaks the rules and will be closed.

I'm sorry if I don't get the reason, and if I'm missing something, please tell me!

(also, a side question, what's the difference between having a mod hide a question and having a mod close a question?)

by
sorry for the absurd question, I just don't really get the point

1 Answer

1 vote
 
Best answer

Closing a question is primarily done for one reason, I believe. If a new user's question is hidden with no explanation, they may not understand what they did wrong, and as such possibly not attempt to ask other questions, thus giving the DB less activity. If the question is closed, however, the asker can easily see where they went wrong, and how to correct that for next time.

It also gives a person ample time to see that their question is against the rules. Like I said before, immediately hiding a question can lead to confusion as to where it went, and what was done wrong. Most closed questions are eventually hidden, but it sometimes stays up for a while, to ensure the asker saw it.

Closing a question still shows the question, and you can still comment and flag it, but no answers can be posted. There's usually a reason as to why it was closed. Hiding a question completely erases it from the public eye, nothing can be done unless the question is reshown. Pokemaster can also delete questions, but this isn't done often.

Hope I helped!

by
selected by
ohhhh never thought of that